Dear Daughter,

Ramping up to your six month growth spurt, I don’t remember how many times we’ve nursed today. I don’t count. I have not counted in a long time, since sometime after your oldest brother was born. (Excluding the little checkboxes that kept me company at the hospital and that drove me nuts as I had to keep finding my phone to get the times when you started and stopped and started again.)

At every doctor’s visit I’m asked how many times you nurse. I say “on demand” and I’m asked for a number.  Do people really count those things? I remember that I nursed you for a half hour when we woke up because I set my alarm so that I can nurse you before I get your oldest brother up for school. I remember that I was nursing you on the floor of the laundry room while I loaded the washer. I know that I nursed you outside while I pushed your brother on the swing but I’m not sure if that counted because you got excited and bit me pretty quickly because you wanted to grab at a moth that flittered by to land on the morning glories overhead. I nursed you at lunch while you tried to grab all my food. I also nursed you a bunch of other times doing all the things that I do all day and every day.

I’m not sure what would happen if I started counting. Would I find it depressing and become concerned about my supply if I found that you nursed fifteen times per day? Would I become paranoid and make you nurse more if you inexplicably only nursed six times a day? Would I be worried if the numbers went up or down by a few times per day?

I go by the brown wetbag hanging upstairs. Each day your diapers fill this bag and make it heavy. Each day the moses basket with all your clean diapers empties itself as you work your way through the supply. Every two days I load the washing machine with your brother’s diapers and yours, and I wash them clean.

I don’t count the number of times I kiss you. I don’t count the number of times that I tell you that I love you. I don’t count the number of times that I tickle you, or sniff your head. But I understand that we are well bonded and that you are firmly attached to me as you recognize me when speak, soothe when I dance with you, and root around to find me when you wake in the dark of the night. Because you squeak only when I’m not there and do not launch instantly into wailing, and your squeaking calms as soon as you are in my arms before you start to nurse.

Numbers like that are for other things and fit poorly into breastfeeding. Breastfeeding is one of those things that is easiest if you simply do it the same way you breathe. Because it is necessary, it is normal, it is automatic, and because you live attached to me in these early days of your life.

Six to eight times would not be enough if I was refusing you when you asked. Fifteen times cannot be too much if it is what you need. We’re not coloring by the numbers, we’re living by your needs.

❤ Mama

S. Avatar

Published by

Categories:

15 responses to “The Number of Times We Nurse”

  1. Louise Avatar
    Louise

    My daughter is 19 months, they’ve stopped asking how many times now! 😉

    Like

    1. sarah Avatar
      sarah

      hah, has it moved to “are you still breastfeeding?” yet? :p

      Like

      1. Louise Avatar
        Louise

        Haha, oh yes. Ages ago. I suspect our doctor thinks it’s no longer nessesary to ask even that. Either that or she’s understood we are a lost case.

        Like

  2. Anneka Avatar
    Anneka

    What actually counts as a “nursing” anyhow? When I’m settling little man sometimes he’ll nurse till he falls asleep, but if I put him down he’ll wake and I’ll nurse him back to sleep again, is that one or two nursings? If it’s two then I’ve probably nursed him 12 times today, if it’s one then probably only 6-8 times…So daft! I just say I don’t know, in the early days I had to keep a diary of his nursings (start time and stop time), some days it’d be 20-30 times, other days just 12… What use is that information anyhow…?

    Like

  3. Gamze Avatar
    Gamze

    I have stopped counting as well but sometimes I wonder and guess for myself but I nurse him for a few minutes at a time sometimes and that is very random like when I just “feel” that he needs it or if he has to poop 🙂 I just remind myself that there are enough wet diapers and let that be enough…

    “I don’t count the number of times I kiss you. I don’t count the number of times that I tell you that I love you. I don’t count the number of times that I tickle you, or sniff your head. But I understand that we are well bonded and that you are firmly attached to me as you recognize me when speak, soothe when I dance with you, and root around to find me when you wake in the dark of the night.”
    This is so wonderful and true.. Exactly how things are and I think should be..

    Like

  4. Marise Avatar
    Marise

    Well said, thank you 🙂

    Like

  5. Kim @ The Bird's Nest Avatar

    Happily, doctors have never asked how much we nurse. They just ask if he is nursing well, to which I say yes, always, and lots! You’re right, it’s second-nature like breathing.

    Like

  6. Jackie Avatar
    Jackie

    well thank you you for writing this !!!!! I do not feel completley alone anymore. I do not pump because I am with my 7 month daughter 24/7. I am always asked how many oz does she drink, how many times and so on. Even BF moms ask me this. I just dont know, I feed her when she is hungry somedays I can tell its less and some more. But I just was starting to feel like I might me the only one. THANK YOU!!!!!!

    Like

    1. sarah Avatar
      sarah

      Definitely not just you. If you’re doing it “right” you generally have no clue, because you don’t pay attention to nutritive/non-nutritive suckling and you don’t use bottles on a regular basis. Best way to breastfeed through to the World Health Organization’s minimum goal of 2years. 🙂

      Like

  7. Simone Avatar
    Simone

    I love this one. Same here… :0)

    Like

  8. Kate Avatar
    Kate

    Hi Sarah,

    I enjoy your blog – although I’m curious to ask you why you write so defensively about nursing? My daughter I think is a day younger than yours, we also EBF. I nurse her to an approximate timetable and additionally on demand if she asks/wakes in the night and needs help settling etc. We have quite a lot of contact with the Heatlth Visitor (and other healthcare professionals, she has a hearing loss so we are often at appointments). Yet I don’t feel we are ever asked or pressed about nursing, how often, how much etc. When asked, they are very happy/accepting of whatever answer I give.

    Do you genuinely feel pressured to be measuring and justifying your methods with every visit? I’ve never felt this way (fortunately) although I’ve found other mums can be quick to say ‘oh that would never work for me’ or ‘but don’t you find…’ Like you, we have found something that works great for our family.

    Sometimes I wonder if writing in this way is by way of ‘promoting an agenda’ – and yes, sometimes it is necessary to lay it on a little thicker to stress the argument (I don’t mean to be rude here!) I’m just curious where you personally feel the judgement comes from and if it is as regular and overbearing as your articles often imply?

    Thanks for the posts, I do enjoy them!

    Like

    1. sarah Avatar
      sarah

      Kate,

      I don’t feel judged at this point. 🙂 Early on in my first breastfeeding relationship when the question was being asked and I was being pressured to conform to some expected schedule of frequent enough but not too frequent, I didn’t feel judged I felt confused and pressured to change something, and I questioned myself and my breastfeeding relationship with my child.

      Now I consider it a pretty useless data point unless there is another issue of concern.

      My point in this particular letter is to share with my daughter that it is a somewhat meaningless question that is often asked and that if It is still being asked when/if she has a child of her own, she should understand how it relates to her supply, baby’s growth, etc.

      I see a lot of women questioning themselves because their baby eats “too many times each day”. And I remember questioning myself. What you may be taking as defensiveness is more my dismissal of the idea that on-demand feeds need to be counted or that the counting of on demand feeds is any more relevant than the number of breaths a healthy person takes per day.

      Like

      1. Becky Avatar
        Becky

        I agree with Sarah, that although the questions are not in and of themselves judgmental, they do have a way of making new moms feel confused and unsure. This is also true for pretty much any parenting book for newborns (with the exception of Sears, probably). My son also nursed/nurses a lot, and he is 14 months. I think he was attached to my breast the first 3 months of his life – no joke. Luckily, my pediatrician never asked about our “schedule”, only doubled checked to make sure we were still nursing. it was the books and other people that made me freak out about how much it seemed he needed to nurse. Now I just go with the flow, literally 😉 Thanks for the post.

        Like

  9. Amanda Avatar
    Amanda

    Thank you for this…I want to share it with every new mama and every mama-to-be that I know (and I probably will). My daughter used to nurse for two hours straight many times per day…but it seemed if I counted it would only be 4-6 “times” even though the total time nursing was far more than my mama friends who nursed 10+ “times” each day. My daughter stopped nursing around a year ago when she was two and a half and I miss it. There was nothing about the number of times OR the duration that mattered to me. What matters is that baby gets what he or she needs and that is a lovely thing. So, again, thank you for writing this…

    Like

  10. […] this:https://nurshable.com/2012/09/28/the-…imes-we-nurse/ As long as your child is gaining and is happy don't worry about it. Your body makes exactly what […]

    Like

Leave a comment