Dear Daughter,

You are only three weeks old and so no one really asks yet about your weaning time.  Those questions will come later, along with the many and varied opinions about when you should be weaned. Having been through this twice before with your older brothers, I already know the answer to this.

Let me share a secret with you. Weaning is misunderstood. It views nursing as an act with a beginning and an end where the end is chosen and a hard drawn line in the sand. It’s not like that.

Nursing is a part of motherhood, of parenthood. It blends in with all of the other things and it fades in from the obligations of pregnancy and then fades out into the series of obligations of a parent to their growing child.

There was no hard drawn line for the start. Even before your birth you drew from my body. You grew within my womb. You were nourished from my placenta. I was your life support system and home while you prepared to be born. It was when you were ready to be born that you signaled to my body that it was time, and it was then that labor began.

Moments after you were born. You squinched your little eyes at me and bobbed your head around and fussed because you understood that there was something to be done, but not what to do.  Instead of sucking, you chomped down. Then you pulled your head back and mewled. We worked together and gradually you learned what to do. And a few days later you stopped biting and set into an easy pattern of nursing that allowed my cracked nipples to heal and my milk to flow.

I do not know the moment that you were conceived. I do not know the moment that your cord stopped pulsing. I do not know the moment that you stopped chomping down and began to nurse.

Some day you will no longer need the sustenance from my body, your suckling reflex will fade away, and instead of turning eagerly toward my breast you will do as your older brother does now as I am writing this. You’ll turn your back to me and curl into my arms in a different way, and you will comfort yourself to sleep with my proximity rather than my breast. And then on another day further into the future you will be even more independent still and instead of curling into my arm you will use my belly as a pillow while you talk to me about Kindergarten friends, as your oldest brother does. And then you will walk back to your own room and your own bed, and you will fall asleep on your own.

I do not know the moment that you will stop nursing. I do not know the moment that you will stop comforting yourself to sleep with the closeness of me. I do not know the moment that you will move off and be fully independent with a life of your own creation. I know that you will do each of these things when it is time for you to do them. And I know that I will smile with pride at your independence even if I want to hold on a little longer.

The commitment that I’ve made to you is life-long. There is no hard start, no hard ending, no fading away of obligation. There is no “weaning” that I plan on doing. There is you. There is your quest for independence. There are the needs that drive your little body and that will fade and change with time. And there is me. My job is simply to be here and meet your needs as you have them. I need neither to push you away nor hold onto you, as you will peel off or cling close according to your needs.

You already have that drive for independence and will take it eagerly at your own pace. Weaning is not something that I need to do. It is something that you will do as an inevitable part of growing up and of life.

I will not hold you back, and I will not push you away. I will not nurse you forever, but I will always be there for you and I will always love you.

❤ Mama

S. Avatar

Published by

Categories:

99 responses to “I Will Not Nurse You Forever”

  1. Michelle Avatar
    Michelle

    Beautifully written, and I applaud the mothers that are able to nurse into toddlerhood. My son just recently weaned himself about 2 weeks ago at around 10 months old. I had been a very low supplier and given him what I could whenever I could, and I was sad to see it end. My MIL was constantly asking when I would stop nursing him, and at first it would bother me, but I finally got over it and finally one day told her to stop asking, I will nurse him as long as he needs me. I think nursing is highly misunderstood in North America as we are so work oriented. It is nice to hear so many success stories. Thanks for writing this!

    Like

  2. ashley Avatar

    lovely post. the pressure to wean is alive and flowing and it is great to see you posting about how unnecessary the whole thing is. what is the rush anyways.

    Like

  3. k Avatar
    k

    i am also getting the “when are you going to stop” from the MIL and from my mom. for two different reasons i think – who can guess why from the MIL… but from my mom i think she’s actually just thinking of me, she nursed me and she knows it takes time, and commitment and i think she just wants to be sure that i’m not losing myself. it’s hard because some days i’m like “i’m done” i’m tired and you are kind of biting me cause you too are tired and no my other boob is not a dial made to occupy your other hand while you nurse…i said i would nurse until you were 14 months and now you are 15 months… but then i look down at her little face and feel the weight of her head on my arm and think ok we’ll keep going for another day. someday we’ll stop but not today.

    Like

  4. Isha Avatar

    This was absolutely beautiful. Soul stirring. I have tears in my eyes. Thank you for writing this.

    Like

  5. Julinda Avatar
    Julinda

    Add me to the list of moms who got a little teary reading this! My boys are 6 and 12 now, breastfeeding is a thing of our past (although I know some 6-year-olds are still nursing and there’s nothing wrong with that), and I will always treasure those moments with the boys. The older one was so adamant uf his baby brother cried – “NURSE him, Mom!” He knew. He remembers and some day I expect him to be saying, “NURSE him, honey” to his future wife! Both my boys, by the way, are well-adjusted and doing great academically!

    Like

  6. Erin Avatar

    So very beautifully said. Thank you!

    Like

  7. Beth Avatar

    Beautiful. I want to go scoop up the baby and nurse her, but we all know the rule about sleeping babies…

    I breastfed my two older kids a few months past a year, but I have this habit of getting pregnant again around that time and I just can’t manage nursing and being pregnant at the same time. It was still a gradual process for both of them.

    I can’t fathom believing that a child being able to walk into their mother’s open arms for any reason-at any age-could be considered damaging.

    Like

  8. Cornelia Slotiuk Avatar
    Cornelia Slotiuk

    Wow, so many feelings….
    I have to believe that ALL mothers want what is best for their babies and kids.
    I also have to believe that EVERY mother has to look at her own life and situation to make big decisions affecting herself and her family.
    And I have to accept that our NA culture does not support new parents well enough.
    I was very lucky to afford to be a stay-at-home mom who nursed her 3 boys well into their second year but I know not all moms can afford that…
    So go on and follow your heart and your head and love your child. Whether you nurse or bottle feed formula or pump or whatever, LOVE YOUR CHILD! Bottom line!

    And by the way…the first bite of solid food at 6 months IS the start of weaning…

    Like

  9. Another time and place Avatar
    Another time and place

    I just came from bed where my 2 year old and 4 year old is sleeping, after I got up my husband took a picture of them holding hands in their sleep after I got up from between them. I really do miss my breastfeeding days, My firstborn stopped by herself and my secondborn really started to hurt me and I made the decision to wean her and have been feeling a bit guilty about it. This post has been very valuable to me in that regard and also made me feel better about the co-sleeping =). So thank you very much.

    Like

  10. tara Avatar
    tara

    Love, love, love this. Absolutely beautiful. Thank you.

    Like

  11. kai n jay mom Avatar
    kai n jay mom

    awww this is beautiful (tears)i am so not looking foward 2 the day that they dont need me i bf my son for 2 months and ive been bf my daughter for4 1/2 months .

    Like

  12. Elizabeth Avatar
    Elizabeth

    I nursed my oldest until he was 20 months and he weaned himself. My youngest nursed steadily until he was 27 months and we weaned together so that I could start medication. I regret it so much…he won’t be small forever and I so miss that time with him…

    Like

  13. LynZ Avatar
    LynZ

    I was unable to have children ONLY due to circumstances around my decision to marry an older man who had 2 of his own, and the fact that the timing was never right. But reading this helps me to understand why – from the time I was about 25 until my current age of 44… I’ve had and still occasionaly have dreams of having (my “dream” baby) nurse me. It always causes me to wake up feeling so emotional and both sad (for not having had children) and happy – for having had the experience from the dream. I’ve always wondered why I have “nursing” dreams. This letter AND ALL OF YOUR RESPONSES sort of helps explain it. Thank you!

    Like

  14. Debbi Avatar
    Debbi

    Thank you “<3 Mama" for your beautiful comments. I have two sons, 28 years old and 33 years old; both breastfed to 13 months and 9 months respectively. I will soon be 60 years old and very pleased I had that time, experience and pleasure of nursing and bonding with both of them. Both weaned on their own. Your comments "<3Mama" say it all…let's remember this is Mother's Day week…"we all did the best we could with the information and support we received at the time!" Happy Mothers Day and week to all of you mothers including mine who breastfed me, too! 🙂

    Like

    1. sarah Avatar
      sarah

      Indeed, Debbi. 🙂 I’m impressed by your nursing journey. 33 years and 28 years ago it was not an easy time to nurse. I’m 32 and my mom talks about how little support she had.

      Like

      1. Debbi Avatar
        Debbi

        Yes, we had little support then. Thank God for the La Leche League. They were my saving grace. But, with that aside I am a registered nurse with a BSN and just recently finished a Lactation Consultant course in San Diego and plan to take the IBLCE Board July 2012 in Orlando. It will be OK! God has a plan for all of us! 🙂

        Like

      2. sarah Avatar
        sarah

        That is awesome, Debbi! IBCLC’s are so valuable to moms that struggle.

        Like

  15. Rae Avatar
    Rae

    I was unable to nurse my firstborn, despite trying for several weeks. Maybe it was because I was young…but I never even had colostrum. I nursed my second for only 6weeks because he had such difficulty digesting my milk, too high in sugar for his liver we were told. This was weird because I don’t have a high sugar diet…but whatever. I did not have any social issues around nursing or not nursing with either child…meaning nobody told me I should be nursing rather than bottle feeding – or alternatively I have never been asked how long I planned to nurse. I bottle fed both my boys until they were ready to give it up…we had cuddle time just as if I were nursing and just as often. They both moved towards and away from me as they were preparing themselves to give up being rocked to sleep. My youngest threw out his own binky when he was ready, and my oldest never wanted one in the first place – nor did either suck their thumbs. I like to think that the nurturing I gave my sons is what provided the encouragement to do as well in their lives as they have. Both are intelligent and very sport oriented…confident, outgoing and kind young men. I don’t believe that they suffered in any way as a result of not being nursed for at least a year. Neither have allergies or other health issues, nor are they smaller than their counterparts who were nursed.
    This is a beautifully written work, and I believe it is intended to address the nurturing a mother does with her child just as much as the nursing.

    Like

  16. Wendy Avatar

    There is nothing I can say that hasn’t been said–such a beautiful post. I too struggled with breastfeeding initially and was sure I wouldn’t make it to six weeks, then three months, then six months, a year . . . Here I am at 14 months + and my daughter and I are still breastfeeding. Unfortunately, I am surrounded by people who look down on extended breastfeeding and so feel as if I’ve been relegated to the closet to avoid the looks and comments of disapproval. As it is, I only breastfeed my daughter in the evenings, mornings and on the weekends (since I work outside of the home). I got a lot of pressure at the year mark to stop. I was even told it was solely for me and I was being selfish–which I absolutely don’t agree with.

    Fortunately, I didn’t listen to those people. My husband, who wasn’t sure at first, only had to look at my daughter and see us together to realize this is right for us. My mom encourages me as well. I am so grateful to them.

    Everything you say is true. I love what that nurse told you. I am going to print your post and keep it handy when I start doubting myself. I don’t know how long I will continue breastfeeding, but I do know that I feel more sure that it is what is best for my daughter–for my family.

    I really like the idea of self-weaning and want her to go at her pace. It feels right, you know?

    It’s such a personal decision and we all have to decide what works best for us. I hate the judgements and negativity being spewed when someone doesn’t agree with someone else’s choice. We are all mothers who love our children and want what is best for them. That should be enough.

    Like

  17. OneMomma Avatar
    OneMomma

    Beautiful work. Thank you. I’m going to put this in with the writings I have made for my daughter, with credit to you of course.

    Like

  18. […] An article about breastfeeding that brought tears to my eyes. —Nurshable […]

    Like

  19. Amanda W Avatar
    Amanda W

    Thank you for this lovely post. My sons self-weaned, my older son at age 2 and my younger son was four years and a few months. I thought my son who nursed until age 4 would remember since he told me my milk tasted like “M & M ice cream” but he doesn’t remember nursing.
    Every mom needs to listen to their heart and do what’s right for them and their baby.

    Like

    1. sarah Avatar
      sarah

      I nursed to 4.5, and my brother nursed to 2.5. I don’t remember it. My brother remembers being weaned. I self weaned, so breastfeeding was just normal. There was no trauma. No more reason to remember it than to remember every meal I ever ate as a child.

      Like

  20. […] as he has been lately on a mix of milk and other foods and after nursing him to sleep I read this article and cried full tears that surprised me with their intensity and resonance. […]

    Like

  21. Emma Burridge Avatar
    Emma Burridge

    Thank you for writing such a beautiful letter to your daughter. I first read it a couple of months ago, and just re-read it, and I’m crying like a baby just like the first time I read it!! I am 21 weeks pregnant and still BF my 16.5 month old daughter. Woudn’t change the BF experience for the world. Will continue to share this on FB. And print it off for my little girl so that one day she will know exactly what I would have written to her, if only I could have put it as eloquently as you! Thank you, health & happiness to you all and all your babies, xx

    Like

  22. Mama, Hear Me Roar Avatar

    What a beautiful post, it expresses perfectly how I feel towards my children. I just found your site and am really looking forward to reading more.

    My 6yo self-weaned around 5yo, my 2nd is still tandem nursing at 4yo with my youngest who is 18mo. They are happy and healthy without any signs of mental damage so far! One of the best things about self-led weaning for my eldest was the joy she had in the decision process. I also feel tandem nursing helped a lot in creating a close bond between the kids. That’s just my experience though, every mother and family is different.

    Like

    1. Gotta leave my 2 cents Avatar
      Gotta leave my 2 cents

      Wow!!! I love nursing my baby! Keyword BABY! Its not necessary past age of 2. They should be eAting and drinking other things AND SLEEPING THRU the night so why is it ever needed to nurse a toddler or preschooler? i think anyone who does it past age of 2 is doing it for comfort maybe even their own comfort not for the child….there are other things that can comfort a kid! If your child is going to pre school, and then nursing at night, my guess is that child will grow up to be very attached and not learn how to self soothe. No one should need to tandem nurse. If you have another baby, the older sibling is not the baby anymore. Past 2 i just dont get but age 5??? !! thats just messed up. Sorry but it is..

      Like

      1. sarah Avatar
        sarah

        Hm? Messed up? What are you basing that statement on?

        Like

      2. Bethany B. Avatar
        Bethany B.

        Tell that to the folks in Mongolia… http://www.incultureparent.com/2011/02/breastfeeding-land-genghis-khan/

        My daughter turned two last month and still nurses in the morning before I go to work, in the evening after we get home, and whenever on the weekends. She sleeps through the night just fine and enjoys a wide variety of foods.

        As far as self-soothing, what is up with that, anyhow? God forbid you comfort your child when they are upset. No, one doesn’t need to give in to every tantrum, but there’s no need to leave them alone to cry themselves out. All they learn from that is that mommy and daddy (and grandma, grandpa, Uncle Joe, and Aunt Sue) don’t care about their feelings. Maybe if people didn’t treat their children from infancy like their feelings and emotions are insignificant compared to an adult, there wouldn’t be so much depression, bullying, and suicide among teenagers. Self-soothing — bah! what bunk!

        Like

  23. Damara Avatar
    Damara

    This was beautiful….made me cry as I struggle with night-weaning and a 14 month old who still doesn’t sleep through the night and nurses 2-4 times in order to get back to sleep. Lovely words.

    Like

  24. mari Avatar
    mari

    absolutely perfectly stated. my heart is warm and my eyes are moist. so glad to have read this today.

    Like

  25. Katleen Avatar
    Katleen

    Thank you for sharing! I am breastfeeding our third child, Sarah, she is 10 months old. I have been feeding her brother till the age of 11 months & her sister till one week before her second birthday. Just like her brother and sister, Sarah can choose herself when she wants to stop. As long as both Sarah and I are happy with it, I will continue to breastfeed her,no matter what other people think of it. 🙂
    It is the most natural thing to do.
    Big hug,
    Katleen

    Like

  26. Helen Avatar
    Helen

    Thanks for posting this! I am still bf my 19mth old son, in the evening before I lay him to bed, we snuggle and he drinks and strokes me. My daughter didn’t breastfeed like him and I had to stop at 11mths for reasons. She took it well. But this one is different. Tell me back when he was born I would still be bf him I would raise a brow. I am even looking forward to the 2 year mark. Funny how you grow into this and learn that you need to follow your instincts on what your child needs. My son has been more loving needed since he was born and is very cuddly. I don’t know if I will keep going on after the 2yr mark as I do miss putting my daughter to bed. We shall see!

    And I am quite confused at Confusion. My husband once said this too when I passed the year mark, but he now sees too that our boy needs this, not so much for nourishment, but for the emotional side to this, the comfort, security etc.
    And as I recall the babes and children in third worlds and more un-modern worlds and not to forget Norway, Sweden etc, they mainly breastfeed and let the littluns wean themselves and also sleep together and carry them and they hardly have any issues with the children in the first years (this seperate from when children go into puberity LOL) We from the modern world and esp the us and europeans tend to box our children up (beds, playpens etc) and push them in foods, learning etc. It’s the way of living for us. Yes I used a playpen and no I did not co sleep in 1 bed. Yes my child slept in my room for the first important months. Yes I carry m y child a lot but also buggy him too. We ask too much of our children while we should just listen to instinct and let them love and play and seek out our safe zone in their years. That makes the world a better place with children more secure of themselves and less judgemental as we were raised to be! Bf or formula, eacht their own opinion allowed, as well as when to wean! But do not make your opinion “the truth” when it is nothing other that YOUR truth and not the worlds truth.. come back with facts.. which you will not be able too and you will realised that you made a boo-boo

    Like

  27. […] I Will Not Nurse You Forever and I Am Not A Human Pacifier, from Nurshable. […]

    Like

Leave a comment