(Please read this first: I Am Not A Better Mother Than You.)

Dear Daughter,

You are three months old, almost everyone agrees that you are too young for “sleep training”, “cry it out”, “Ferberization” and all those other methods of sleep training that the parenting circles buzz about. Others say that three months is plenty old enough. Everyone has their rules, their ages, their advice, their books, their suggestions.

With your oldest brother I became anxious and felt like I was doing “nothing” to help him learn to sleep. With you, I smile peacefully when offered advice about getting you to sleep. I know that I’m not doing “nothing”, I’m laying the foundation slowly and gently.

Chances are pretty good that you’re reading this as an adult and thinking “I love to sleep! Sleep feels awesome.” and snuggling under your covers hitting the snooze button repeatedly.

You’re at the infant stage where to be held is comfort. When I put you down and you cry I don’t k now why it is that you’re crying. I’m told that you “want to be held” and that you are “spoiled” and that “you need to learn to self soothe”.

The thing is.. Sometimes we want comfort because something bothers us. Sometimes we’re rocked by the waves of life and battered by stresses. Sometimes we cling to those we love because we seek solace in comfort. Sometimes we cry because of pain or discomfort but find peace and calm in the arms of someone that we are close to. This applies to adults who have all the words in the world to communicate their needs and to understand them. To adults who have had years to fine-tune their ability to self comfort.

Since you have no words, I do not know the meaning behind your cries. And since you are an infant, I do not choose to attribute malice or aforethought to your cries that soothe as soon as I pick you up. I do not view you as a cunning little creature that wishes to interfere with my life by insisting on being near me.

Maybe you have reflux that makes laying down painful. Maybe you have a belly ache. Maybe you are anxious because of a noise, or afraid of the dark. Maybe you simply do wish to be held because my arms are the safest and warmest place in your world. Maybe your instincts speak loudly to you in ways that you do not understand and you simply know that right now you need to be held in order to be calm.

I cannot think of any reason why I should feel okay letting you lay there screaming. Yes, I need sleep. Of course I need sleep. And I snatch that sleep where I can. Yes, I like sleep. I love sleep. I’ve acquired that taste for lazy days of lounging around in bed. Lazy days that I can’t remember the last of. I have words to vocalize these needs of mine. I have people that I can speak with, and I can even make a stab at  saying it eloquently. “I need sleep.” Sometimes I’m so tired that I could cry with that need for sleep.

I am grown. I am strong. I understand the passage of time and that THIS will pass. You will sleep. Your infancy is the briefest part of the brief time that you are a child in need of my arms.

I can wait it out so that you don’t have to cry it out.

I can wait until you have the words to explain your needs and until I can use my words to help you understand the deliciousness and safety of the dark warm place that is your bed in the night in your room in your home with mommy and daddy just a door away. I can rock with you in the dark and let my thoughts and dreams wander and savor the stinky sweet baby smell of your hair and feel the wakings spacing out and coming together as you grow through growth spurts and phases.

I put you down and smile at you in your bed as you stare up at the ceiling fan and smile. You learn that your bed is a safe place to be while awake. When you fuss or cry I pick you up and tell you “I know, you want to be held right now.” You learn that your bed is not a place where you are abandoned, but rather a place that you can happily be while awake.

I nurse you when you need to nurse, trusting you to know your needs and your hunger.

I smile at you and talk to you about how snuggly and warm your pajamas are. How sleepy and relaxed you look. I stroke your cheek and let you savor the sleepiness as you drift off feeling safe.

As you get older like your brothers have, I will do these same things. I will stretch things out and treat bedtime with no urgency or anxiety. I will talk to you as I have to them about relaxing every bit of your body and how your bed is so safe and warm and snuggly and how you can feel the sleepiness in your feet, your legs, your belly, your arms.. How you sink into your mattress and your pillow and how finally your eyes are heavy and sleepy and they barely stay awake because you are so tired that you just… fall… asleep.

Then I can simply remind you “You need to close your eyes and relax.” And I can start telling you that I will be back to check on you as I need to do my bedtime chores.

I’m more worried about how I will convince you to get out of bed when you’re a teenager than I am about the idea that you will never self soothe or that you will never sleep in your own bed. I want you to truly enjoy going to sleep at the end of your long and eventful days, I don’t want you to simply lay there with your eyes awake waiting for sleep while counting sheep as I do the same thing one room over. I want to teach you all the things that I’ve learned about falling asleep, rather than leaving you as an infant to somehow figure it out on your own.

I can savor bedtime and wait it out, because this will not last forever. You are a little creature that is bent on independence. All I need to do is help you see sleep for what it is. Safe, comfortable, and lovely.

❤ Mama

Follow up: “Learning to Self Soothe (WIO)

S. Avatar

Published by

Categories: ,

282 responses to “The WIO (Wait It Out) Method of Sleep Training”

  1. Crystal Avatar
    Crystal

    From the bottom of my heart, thank you. I don’t know if I can truly describe in words how greatful I am for this beautiful letter you’ve written. It has changed my outlook completely on what is best for my daughter. We have been struggling for six months now to get her to sleep in her own bed, she was fine early in life and now that she’s three refuses to stay in her room in her own bed. It’s like theres a bright light shining showing me the way now. Thank you for helping me put this sleep deprivation stage into perspective! Now instead of feeling hopeless due to lack of sleep & alone time with the husband, I will be greatful for the opportunity to be the loving arms my daughter obviously needs.

    Like

    1. sarah Avatar
      sarah

      At three I started explaining to my son how to relax and get sleepy from his toes, his legs, etc. After I made sure he understood how to relax, I’d start saying “I need to go get a drink of water, I’ll check on you in five minutes. If you’re still in bed I’ll lay down with you for a little bit”. Then I’d come back, lay down with him for a bit, and then go do another bedtime chore and return, lay down, etc. There were no tears because he was old enough to understand, and he was at an emotional place where he was okay with that.

      I slowly modified that to just checking on him in 15 minutes and he was usually asleep by that time. If he wasn’t I’d kiss him on the forehead, remind him how to relax, and come back in another 15 minutes. At five it is something that he likes and prefers but not something that he NEEDS. I still do it because it makes me smile. He sleeps like a log until I pluck him out of bed for school/camp in the morning.

      Like

  2. Liseanne Avatar
    Liseanne

    Love it! So beautiful! I have not at all regretted waiting it out with my daughter, who is 3. She always slept a lot, but needed help in staying/falling asleep. She needed to be with us (my husband and I). Slowly, she began to wake less and less. Was I tired? Yes, I was. Was it worth it? Yes, it was. Around 2 she started asking to go to sleep in her own bed. She started asking to read books by herself. It was such a smooth, beautiful transition – proved to me that it will happen, when the child is ready.

    Like

  3. Jennifer Avatar
    Jennifer

    This is the exact name I was looking for for how I feel about my precious baby! Thanks for giving me a name for it! This is oh so perfect! So glad God lead me to your blog! Will be printing for my sweet baby girl’s baby book too!!! God bless you and your words of love and encouragement!

    Like

  4. Erin Avatar
    Erin

    Love this! thank you, this is exactly how I feel and I’m glad someone said something and said it so well.

    Like

  5. Savanah Fahrney-Day Avatar

    Thank you! We were having a terrible time with bedtime last month. Creating a “bed” room helped. Now all four boys sleep in the same room, making it easier to help everyone calm down and fall asleep without a fight. Its hard to deal with people saying I’m nuts for putting them all together or that I should just tell them goodnight and be done with it.

    Like

  6. Saloni Bhardwaj Avatar
    Saloni Bhardwaj

    Gosh!! my daughter is 10weeks old & i have been dealing with the exact same situation/emotion. My son- born exactly a year before his sister gave us a challenging time with his sleep. So everyone has a say & of course I am a bit nervous too. But I can`t hear my child cry & cuddle them. Thank you for reassuring my belief in ‘spoiling’ my children.

    Like

  7. su Avatar
    su

    thanks a mill!!! my gut feeling always told me that this cry out and negativity “she is playing you” ect. can’t be intended from nature. why should there be any bad bone in baby? mine is now 22 months not sleeping through the night, still being breastfed at night. going to bed at 8pm with a book, coming for the boob at midnight, and then for her morningfeed between 5-7am. she is the most adorable little girl, and i can live with it. it is such a short time anyways. funny i also always thought i will spend more time getting her out of the bed then into it.

    Like

  8. Emma Avatar
    Emma

    Thank you for this. Beautiful writing and beautiful sentiments. Sometimes during a hard night it is difficult to remember why I am doing the things I am doing so it is lovely to have this kind of reminder/reinforcement.

    Like

  9. Jamie Kay Avatar
    Jamie Kay

    First off let me say I love this ” letter to my daughter.” I am a new mom my little Emma is 3 months. We co-sleep which I thought I never would do, I’m still nursing her a d pumping the rest of her food. I am one of the lucky ones! She has been sleep about 8 hours straight through the night since about 2 months! Very lucky from what I hear. I am a person who desperately needs sleep. The first two months were so so hard for me. But we got through it and thankfully ahe now sleeps at least 8 hours straight!
    I had no idea about WIO method although I 100% agree with it! This letter put into words how I feel. Now on the other hand I don’t know what I would do if for months and months and months Emma wouldn’t sleep hardly and kept me up all night?! I might try Juat about anything out of deperation lol. Thankfully I don’t have to;) Also to the one who wrote this letter, everytime I’ve read this out loud I get chocked up and almost start crying. It touches a sensitive place inside me and I thank u for giving my thoughts and feelings words!;) I had nk idea there was such debate on this topic until I started reading the comments. Wow. Ultimately you have to do what right for you and you child and not everyone and there situation fit into the same box with the same solutions! good luck to all the moms! ❤

    Like

  10. Danielle Avatar
    Danielle

    I want to sincerely thank you. My 9 month old daughter is sleepin soundly on my chest as I type this, and I am at peace with that fact. I have struggled for the past 9 months with all of the advice and expectation placed upon my daughter. I can’t tell you how many times I have been told to let her CIO. My heart just can’t take her crying, so we co-sleep. As much as I love having this beautiful baby sleep next to me I have never really felt at peace with my decisions. Free reading many of your letters to your children, I know now that I am doing what works for us and I should enjoy every passing second as much as possible. Thank you, thank you, thank you, from the bottom of my heart.

    Like

  11. Cindy Avatar
    Cindy

    I love this letter. It expresses what I have been doing with my own daughter, now 23 months old. We coslept and nursed to sleep every night, holding her in my arms for naps for months and months until she could lay on her own while sleeping. While she still needs mama next to her to drift off, she had been sleeping through the night 11+hours for quite some time. I feel like while I am not the most patient person and I fight my impatience as a mother daily, my nighttime interactions with my daughter are the best thing I have done for her.
    Last night, when she wanted to go to sleep in her “big girl” toddler bed I was nervous and pleased. It took five minutes of me laying near her for her to fall asleep, which I am happy to give her. And she slept alone at night for the first time ever.
    Basically, I want to say thank you for your beautifully written sentiment that responds to my own instincts and goes against every person who has given me grief over sleep.

    Like

  12. Lori Avatar
    Lori

    So happy to have read this, I read the baby whisperer and have been trying the pick up put down method and it has been a nightmare. I just want to hold him and comfort him till he gets sleepy. I decided yesterday that I will do it my way and not by a book. I’m glad that there are other people that don’t think it is a crime that I comfort my baby to sleep.

    Like

    1. sarah Avatar
      sarah

      I hate the pick up put down method. It results in a lot of screechy. It might work for some babies but not mine. The gradual approach and waiting until they’re able to understand language and communicate works just fine for me. I have two older kids that sleep through the night (unless they are sick or have a nightmare)

      It’s about approach. We establish a bedtime routine then do anything necessary to get our children to fall asleep during that routine. Later when they can understand language and concepts then we talk to them and ease them into falling asleep on their own.

      My two year old will currently fall asleep laying next to someone with his head or back being rubbed and has started falling asleep after just being laid down in his bed if he’s tired. He puts himself back to sleep when he wakes up unless something is bothering him. My five year old has been able to fall asleep on his own since he was 3 or so.

      I understand some parents want their 7 month old or their one year old to fall asleep without needing comfort. I don’t personally have that desire or need. Bedtime is wind-down family time where we reconnect. When I’m consistent with providing routine and comfort my children fall asleep quickly and comfort back to sleep quickly.

      Like

  13. rebecca Avatar
    rebecca

    thank you for putting into words what my partner and I decided 5 years ago to do with our twins. beautiful.

    Our perspective was always that people often spend years of their life trying to crawl back into bed with someone – sometimes in unhealthy ways – perhaps that normal, healthy need for closeness and peace at bedtime (and other times) should not be denied so young…

    we also wondered why crying at night to express a need is different than crying during the day to express a need…

    then, it turned out that one of our two had insomnia. hours of wakefulness at night. exhausted mama, to be sure, but i’m convinced that if we had tried to force her to find a way to go to sleep on her own that it would have been damaging to her in terms of her sense of security and trust in us.

    and i found the long nights to be an opportunity to practice patience and gentleness.

    i had those, including a doctor, who said i would just “have to” let her cry at some point. we didn’t.

    my now-5 year old non-insomniac sleeps like a log until morning – as does my dear insomniac unless she’s having one of those nights. fortunately, those nights are growing fewer and further between.

    it worked/works for our kids.

    Like

  14. Susan T Avatar
    Susan T

    It is so encouraging for me to read that many of you are so patient with your babies- gives me more hope for the future 🙂 So thankful that the “Skinner-ian” practice of training children scientifically like animals w/no feelings has not completely overtaken your generation. (Ezzo was BIG when I had small children and then/now ((maniac)) Pearl) Now my 3 children are young adults and they too are thankful that there are thinking, feeling young parents just ahead of them. 

    Other potential benefits of your gentle night parenting are support of longer nursing, which keeps hormones more even for you(and possibly reduces breast cancer risk) and breastmilk continues to provide perfect nutrition for young children which continues to complete brain cell development beyond infancy, and of course breastmilk provides the perfect antibiotic for whatever childhood illness your little one encounters.

    Like

  15. Joanna Avatar
    Joanna

    You are brilliant for putting in to understandable and beautiful words that our generation can understand what brilliant old school therapists like D. Winnicott were trying to share. Thank you thank you thank you! I will share with many of my clients and friends! Joanna

    Like

  16. Michelle Avatar
    Michelle

    This is lovely. I cuddled my son to sleep every night until past his first birthday, until one night he pushed me away and lent towards his cot where I placed him and he went to sleep himself. He is now coming up to 22 months old and while he will sit and cuddle downstairs before bed, once we go upstairs he just wants a kiss and to be put in his cot where he happily goes to sleep. I’m pleased he sees his bedroom as a place of peace and comfort. We never did any method of sleep training, we were lucky not to need to. He likes his bed. :o)

    Like

  17. […] topic. The mother’s name is Sarah, and her website is Nurshable. The title of this blog is  “The WIO (Wait It Out) Method Of Sleep Training.” “Dear Daughter, You are three months old, almost everyone agrees that you are too young for […]

    Like

  18. Esperanza Avatar

    You say this is just a letter to your daughter, though it obviously is more than that because you chose to put it on this website. You also say (in a response to a comment) that you find CIO icky. I’m sure you realize that sentiment shines through here, loud and clear.

    I’m sorry non-attachment parents tell you you are creating a clingy, needy child who will not sleep. It is no one’s business to say anything else to anybody about the way they parent. But please understand that by writing this letter, in this way, posting it here, and responding to comments in the way that you have, you are doing the same thing to parents who have chosen CIO. It’s very clear how you feel about CIO and the judgment you project toward people who use that method. Please know that.

    Like

    1. sarah Avatar
      sarah

      Your thoughts are welcome, even if I do not necessarily agree with them.

      I see this as my space to share things. The things that I choose to share may not be all encompassing and may have a strong viewpoint, but I don’t see why you feel that my view in particular is judgemental in a way that necessitates my being called out on it within my personal space. I have read articles that have outright called CIO child abuse. That seems like it would be a better place to critique a person’s thoughts.

      I share my views publicly because others share their views publicly. If you read the other comments on this letter, and the comments elsewhere on the internet, many MANY mothers are being made to feel “guilty” for not sleep training their child. Not because they want more sleep, but because people are telling them that they HAVE to train their child to sleep.

      I would like to say this: My intentions are to tell other mothers that if your heart tells you that CIO is wrong, then it is not the right choice for you, and that is OKAY.

      If I wanted to say that mothers who allow their children to CIO are horrible abusive parents, I would say so. I have not said so because I do not believe that is the case and I do not believe that life is that black and white.

      Yes, I raise an eyebrow at certain things such as the idea that infants can be manipulative. But I do not think that ALL cio-ers feel that their children are manipulative.

      This is not a letter for mothers who feel that CIO is the best or only option. This is a letter for mothers whose hearts are telling them “don’t”, and more specifically it is a letter for my daughter so that if she is ever told that she has to use CIO with her children.. She knows that she doesn’t HAVE to and that there are other options.

      If you can find one community of hardcore sleep trainers that I have posted this to, or one time that I have said that I consider CIO abusive, or any place where I have slammed CIO as a whole rather than picking particular aspects of it that befuddle me.. Please tell me. Otherwise I’m going to stay a little bit confused as to why you feel that I’m being so attacky and mommy-warsy.

      Yes. I do find CIO icky. The idea of using it with my own children is very uncomfortable for me. Which is why I don’t tell other parents what to do. Maybe the thing that I feel is correct in my heart makes another parent as unhappy and anxious and sad as CIO would make me.

      I don’t know what’s in another person’s heart or mind or life or beliefs. I can’t tell them what to do. There is no universal parenting method that will work for everyone, and I realize that. I wouldn’t even want to tell my daughter or my sons how they HAVE to parent. I don’t even tell dad how he has to parent.

      CIO is not for me. And if CIO is for you, then this letter to my daughter might not be applicable for you. Maybe there’s a loving letter somewhere about CIO that you can read instead. 🙂

      Like

      1. Esperanza Avatar

        I just wanted to say thank you for your thoughtful response to my comment. I understand that we’re not going to see eye to eye on this and that is okay.

        I think I felt attacked because when I find someone else parenting practices to be “icky” I really don’t agree with them, and not just that they are not okay for me but that they are practices that do more harm, universally, than good. There are very few parenting practices that I feel that way about. I may not understand the desire to night parent in the way that you do but I don’t find it “icky” and it doesn’t make me uncomfortable. I just know that it will not be what makes me and my child happy (and yes I do believe that my child is MUCH happier as a result of sleep training. She is a different child from the overtired baby who got very little sleep). I’m willing to admit that this is mostly my own issue, although the other comments in line with mine lead me to believe that I’m not the only one who felt the way I did.

        You’re right, I could be spending my time reading a letter to a child who was slept trained but honestly I’ve never come across one. I’ve never come across any parenting site that so deeply extols the benefits of the way I choose to parent. I don’t know why that is. I guess it’s just a different mindset.

        Maybe I should go write that letter myself. And if I do, I’ll be very careful not to suggest that those who choose not to CIO are doing a disservice to their children or themselves.

        Like

      2. sarah Avatar
        sarah

        “Icky for me”. 🙂 Maybe I just have a wide range of friends, but I have friends that use CIO, that circumcise, that pierce their baby’s ears, that spank, that formula feed, that forward face in car seats at a year, that have their newborns sleep in a different bedroom, etc. All things that feel icky applied to MY kids.

        Then I also have friends who are vegan, gluten free, and never watch TV with their kids, and who homeschool.

        There is “icky” for me, “too hard” for me, and “I WISH”.

        The parenting practices I actually judge the parents in are not “icky-for-me-” they are abusive or negligent. And even then I often feel sorry for the parents because many of them were simply not taught better coping skills, or are simply following what they know. (I obviously feel worse for the kids in this case).

        Like

  19. Linda Avatar
    Linda

    My boys are now grown men, ages 25 and 28. I practiced WIO along with attachment parenting and extended nursing. Both were fussy infants who needed nursed every so many hours, day and night, until well into toddlerhood. We practiced shared sleeping, weaning each child into his own bed by the age of three or four. I slept when the kids slept, tucking them both into bed with me for naps.

    The youngest turned out to be autistic, and unlike the “normal” autistic person loved to be touched, hugged and cuddled. His eye contact was poor, but not with me – he’d gaze into my eyes while nursing. He’s now very affectionate and loves to hug people that he loves. He still has autism, but he’s extremely high-functioning – enough that he’s getting his PhD in Atmospheric Sciences (weather and climate-related) and taking a trip to Germany next week to give a presentation.

    His brother is the “the IT guy” at a small non-profit. He’s not bashful about giving affection and never was. Is he perfect? No, of course not. But I’m very proud of how he turned out. He’s happily married to a wonderful woman and they’re in the process of working on getting me a grandchild.

    To the Moms who are feeling overwhelmed right now I have this to say: Sure, you’re tired. You have one of those kids who nurses round the clock and you feel “touched out” by the end of the day. Your sex life leaves something to be desired because you’ve held a human being all day long and frankly want some space when you can get it. The house is a mess, the diaper pail is near to overflowing, and you would die for eight straight hours of sleep. Your husband wants to take you out to eat – guess what? The baby won’t cooperate and the toddler always throws a tantrum in restaurants. So, once again, it’s either having Chinese delivered or another meal from the crock-pot, which you now think is your best friend.

    I could ramble on and on, but what I’m getting at, in my rather roundabout way, is that none of this lasts forever. One day that baby of yours will be getting his high school diploma and you’ll wonder how the years slipped by so quickly. His first car, his first girlfriend (or boyfriend, if he’s so inclined), his gang of friends that all call YOU Mom, his first tooth, or his first trip in an airplane to Germany … it all comes and goes so quickly. You WILL get your sleep, you’ll rediscover your sex life, and you’ll be able to go to movies and eat out in nice restaurants again.

    My final word of advice is this: Pay no mind to what THEY say is the “right” way to train your baby. Go with your gut instinct. Also, remember that to “spoil” something is to neglect it and let it rot. You can’t spoil a baby; they’re not manipulative. A baby’s wants are a baby’s needs. A toddler’s wants… not so much their needs. Ditto your twelve-year-old’s wants. There’s a difference.

    Good luck to all of you and Goddess Bless!

    Like

  20. TheGuyInTheRoom Avatar
    TheGuyInTheRoom

    Does this woman have a job?

    Like

    1. Linda Avatar
      Linda

      I most certainly DO have a job – one that requires a college education and a computer-techie mind. Thanks for asking, though. 🙂

      Like

  21. Hannah Avatar
    Hannah

    Love this! So many people didn’t understand why we did WIO (love that there is a term now for that). And we didn’t have an easy sleeper by any means. Ours was the baby who, due to severe reflux, despite the medication, would still wake every 2 hours, at least. And she was the one who would stir as soon as we laid her down. We did have to hold her most nights asleep until we went to bed because she wouldn’t stay asleep if we put her in the bed. But praise God, it got better. She still crawls in bed with us in the early morning most nights but we don’t mind that at all. And she never dreads sleep. And she’s healthy. And… our marriage is stronger than ever because through that trying time we learned to be more patient and more empathic with each other. So, for anyone who is feeling discouraged, please know that it does get better and it can improve your marriage, not destroy it. 🙂

    Like

  22. Jess Avatar
    Jess

    What a beautifully written article. My daughter is 11 months old, and her sleeping habits have changed several times. I have nursed her to sleep, rocked her to sleep, swaddled, put her in the swing, and sometimes she’d just fall asleep on her own in her bed. We have let her cry it out before, because none of those options would help. It pained us to listen to it, but sometimes you get so frustrated that it’s better for baby if you just walk away for a few minutes. Now she’s back in the phase where she prefers me to hold her to go to sleep, and I love the bonding every night. There is no right or wrong way, whatever works for your family and raises a happy, healthy child, go for it. I wish there was not so much judgement in the Mommy world.

    Thank you for sharing this beautiful letter to your daughter.

    Like

    1. sarah Avatar
      sarah

      Yes, if you cannot let go of the frustration, it is best to put baby down. They can feel the frustration and upset and it all escalates. With my first I had some of these occasions, with my second I had fewer because I understood that it would pass. With my third I have discovered that CHOOSING WIO and understanding that I will not be getting much sleep.. It has made me way more mellow. It’s hard. And when you are being told that the child should be sleeping by now, it is harder.

      Like

  23. Joan Avatar
    Joan

    This is a wonderful and inspiring letter. The CIO Moms in this email string that are critiquing it need to look internally at what is really bothering them. I am sure I could be wrong, but to me it sounds like guilt being expressed as anger. Maybe you should go find another website to commiserate with people who made a similar choice and leave Sarah alone. She has made a choice, so have you. Go live with your choice and express yourself somewhere else.

    Like

    1. Kira Avatar
      Kira

      Joan, this is exactly the attitude that I am talking about in my post (just below yours). I would like to think that all mothers are taking the time to look inside and making the best decisions they can for their children. I could just as easily psychoanalyze your choice (and I love your choice..I admire your choice) but I won’t. Because I believe you are a wonderful mother…and I also believe that I am too.

      As for Sarah – this is a beautiful letter. But if she chooses to post it online and share it with the world on a blog that welcomes comments, then she is also choosing to hear what others think about it.

      Like

      1. sarah Avatar
        sarah

        I do welcome comments, even those that judge my words or choices. 🙂

        Like

  24. Kira Avatar
    Kira

    This is a beautiful letter to your daughter, and I admire your ability to WIO. Just as I admire any mother’s ability to do what is right for them and for their children. For me, I am a mother twins (naturally conceived, so no, I was not prepared for this). I am also a person who doesn’t survive well on very little sleep. I am not the mother I wish to be when I am tired. So for me, what was right for my children was to give them the mother they deserve…and trust me, they deserve so much better than the sleep-deprived version of me. And so we did sleep training. Remember, not all mothers are blessed with the opportunity to hold and comfort their children whenever they need it. How does one do that when two of them are struggling at the same time? For their own sake, it was necessary to teach them some self-soothing as it isn’t possible for me to fill that role whenever I want…though I wish that I could. I admire women who sleep train, I admire women who don’t. My frustration comes from the women who are judging each other. I’m not saying that is what you are doing here, but letter’s like this, when published, open the door for such judgement. Aren’t we all looking to do what is right by our kids? Shouldn’t we assume that this is so?

    Like

    1. sarah Avatar
      sarah

      An informed choice made of love and necessity is never the wrong choice. You love your children, understand your life, and make the choices that you need to make for your family. Drink it in, love them deeply, and don’t accept any guilt that others try to hand you. You alone know your life, and you alone make the choices that keep you and your family healthy.

      My letter is a written expression of my filtering the things that I am told through the daughter that I see in my arms. Not an indictment of others. Yes, there is a world of judgement floating around out there as everyone thinks that they have somehow found the magic method to parenting. They are lucky. Most of us struggle with being inundated with advice that simply does not fit our children or our lives, and we have to filter things.

      One of the things that I have to filter is advice from those that advocate CIO. I also have to filter advice from those that advocate complete indulgence.

      My letter to my daughter does not judge you for the methods that you use, it judges the methods that others tell me I MUST use.

      Regrettably some people will use my letter as a bitter angry thing to make moms feel guilty. Just as many moms that use CIO attempt to make moms that don’t sleep-train feel guilty. That is a misuse of my words.

      My words are directed to moms like me, for whom CIO is NOT the right choice, who are being told left and right that their baby “needs” to cry, and that to not let them cry is to deprive them and teach them the fine art of manipulation.

      My words are to relieve guilt wrongfully imposed. For people to share with others who are attempting to force them to change how their heart says to parent. As an explanation not as a weapon to inflict guilt on others.

      If you are making an informed loving and difficult decision for the good of your children and your family, there is NO guilt to be had there even if your methods are different from mine. Guilt comes from selfishness, not from a balancing of needs.

      No anonymous stranger, no nosey sister in law, no high school friend will ever love your baby as much as you do.

      Like

      1. Kira Avatar
        Kira

        Beautifully put as was your letter. Thank you for acknowledging that. It is good to know that some of us out there are trying our best to live free of judgement.

        Like

  25. […] I thought you might like to read this blog post. I make no connection between this and anything else she has to say… I don't follow her blog but thought this was nice, particularly in CC comments today. https://nurshable.com/2012/07/19/the-…leep-training/ […]

    Like

  26. Charity Avatar
    Charity

    I love this post. I have a question. My daughter is almost 10 mo. and I have another one coming in March. How close were your children together and how did this bedtime routine work with a new baby. We are going to try the Sleep Lady technique not letting her CIO but I am not sure it will really work and am worried how the new baby will fit in. How did it work with your sons? Did they go to sleep first?

    Like

  27. carolyn kalisch Avatar
    carolyn kalisch

    if only someone had written this 33 years ago. i felt guilty when my babies cried when i left them, which wasn’t long i couldn’t bear to hear their little hearts break, but i felt guilty that i picked them up too, because you just didn’t let that little one be the boss, which confused and maybe affected the way i felt about my mothering skills. so i say hip hip hooray to this wonderful insightful mum. enjoy the moment, they are babes for only a short time.

    Like

  28. Elena Avatar
    Elena

    THANK YOU! Thank you for being so gentle, wise, and giving mommma! And for shining your light and making our paths lighter!

    Like

  29. Elena Avatar
    Elena

    I should’ve read before posting:) Let me correct myself, pls:
    Thank you for being such a gentle, wise, and going mamma! And for shining your light and making our paths brighter!

    Like

  30. CS Avatar
    CS

    Such a lovely blog. I waited it out with my little boy too whilst everyone around me looked at me pityingly that he wasn’t sleeping through yet at 5 months! It’s just 5 months… only 5 sleep deprived months of my life where I got to hold and cuddle and soothe my beautiful baby boy. From about 6 months he started sleeping through and now, at 8 months, crawling and exploring with his newfound independence, I’m lucky if a get a cuddle! Why do people want to rush this oh so short and precious stage. Well done for articulating it so beautifully.

    Like

  31. holding babies « My Epic Motherhood Avatar

    […] wanted to post this link. It’s a letter from a mother to her baby daughter. It’s a beautiful description of why […]

    Like

  32. Nansi Avatar
    Nansi

    Thank you so much for sharing this wonderful story. That what I really need at this moment when they told me the only way to teach my 6 months old son to self soothing with crying it out method which something that I always against. I’m going to print this and will share it with other new moms who struggling with the idea of crying it out method.

    Like

  33. Tiffany Avatar
    Tiffany

    I love this, simply love it. You put into words exactly how I feel, but so often don’t say or explain to others. I sometimes feel guilty, or rushed, or bad if I can’t get my daughter to fall asleep in a timely fashion. But then the moments I have as I rock her, helping her sleep, I realize I would not trade that time for anything else in the world. I rock her, or nurse her, or hold her to sleep because that is what my instincts as a mother tell me to do. And she is happy, secure, comfortable and healthy (11 mos old). I choose to wait it out because I feel it is the best I can do as a mother, not the easiest. Thanks for writing this.

    Like

  34. meredith Avatar
    meredith

    dear sarah, WONDERFUL post!!!

    to all the mamas out there who, like you, are inclined to follow their guts/hearts and respond to their crying babies, i would like to offer this: my 7-y.o. is a great sleeper, and she was never left to cry in the night as an infant/toddler/preschooler. a need for closeness is as legitimate a need as hunger, and i will never regret my responsiveness. all those CIO advocates would’ve had me believe that i was creating bad sleep habits — malarkey!
    rock on attached mamas (and daddys, and grandparents and aunties…)!

    -meredith

    Like

  35. Brooke Avatar
    Brooke

    I call it “ride it out” & this is exactly what I feel about my daughter’s sleeping!

    Like

    1. sarah Avatar
      sarah

      Brooke, if you dub it the “Ride It Out Theory” then you can call it RIOT. I like that even better than WIO. 😉

      Like

  36. Marisa Avatar
    Marisa

    So as a new grandmother whose daughter (first time mother) sent me this link, I am touched by your sweet sentiments regarding parenting your daughter as well as your sons. Thank you for publishing them. It was very encouraging to my daughter as she grows in her parenting. First time around, you feel so uncertain and inadequate.

    CIO was also popular 24 years ago but tried it once with the above child and never did it again. Just was not effective and personally heartbreaking. What did work was letting her nurse for an hour every night until limpness — I guess she got “drunk” because she would sleep through except for one very brief visit in the middle of the night. My perspective was (and is) that it’s such a short time in our lives that we WILL get through it. Our babies only know they have a need and can only cry to express it, not explain it. They also don’t understand the concept of the passage of time until elementary school … and even then you wonder as they shower endlessly as teenagers! My subsequent children also shared a room from early on which solved much of fears of being alone. Thanks again, Sarah.

    Like

  37. Sammie Avatar

    I HAD to comment just so you could be continuously reminded that this was AWESOME. I know you’ve had comments on this post attacking you for having your opinion on what is best for YOUR children–people in this country love to attack others without using their brains first. CIO didn’t work for us with my 1st daughter, and I refuse to feel pressured to try it with #2 due in a few months. You letter is clearly written from a perspective of a mother who realizes that just because something is “popular” and that “all the experts say…” doesn’t make it right & certainly doesn’t work for every baby. Every mother must do what’s best for HER chilren even if it isn’t what the “experts” say. Bravo!

    Like

  38. Kerri Avatar
    Kerri

    I wholeheartedly agree with this post. And don’t understand why people are feeling attacked. I have 2 very good friends who CIO from a very early age. I did use CIO for my daughter who would NOT settle with nursing or rocking or swaddling or snuggling, and having 3 kids 3 and under, with the oldest having a speech delay, I was on the verge of losing my ever-loving mind. I did what I had to do in that situation, evaluating MY life and MY situation. I didn’t find the need to use CIO with my other 3 kids, and she was #3, so not like it’s my first rodeo 🙂 I still love my friends who CIO, I still love myself, and I love my children equally.

    Why all the polarization? Why all the defensiveness? If you feel guilty about a choice you made from reading a blog post about it, then maybe it really doesn’t feel right to you still. Maybe you might not choose the same thing next time. Sparring over CIO vs WIO is the same as breast vs bottle, rf vs ff and any other countless “mommywars”.

    I’m all about survival. Do what you have to do to get through infancy. For most of my kids, WIO worked. For one CIO was the answer. I don’t feel the need to justify my choice to WIO or my choice to CIO with one of my children. I don’t feel attacked or guilty or put upon by someone else’s OPINION…

    Like

  39. mariankafer Avatar

    Another voice that just wants to say thanks for writing this. I had been WIO without knowing it for the last 8 months with my little man. Family, friends and the ever-present “they” have all suggested that an 8-month old should be sleeping through the night by now! We caved to the pressure of trying to “sleep train” for naps… never again. I have come to terms with the fact that this is only temporary. Now I just need to find a way to better deal with all those helpful people who want to know “how’s he sleeping???”

    Like

    1. sarah Avatar
      sarah

      I read an awesome response somewhere. “He is sleeping like a baby.” People assume that means all night through. 😉 You get to be truthful (babies sleep terribly) but avoid the details all at once.

      Like

  40. Aubrey Avatar

    I just want to tell you that in light of all the negativity I’ve read on here that I see your blog for what it is – YOUR opinion and YOUR way of doing things. No one is required to read your blog or agree with it. I’ve never thought you were out to make others feel badly. I love your writing and have found comfort in it many times. Please don’t change a thing.

    Like

  41. Rachel Avatar
    Rachel

    Thank you for this! I am new to your blog and a new momma. I am struggling with feeling judged by family and friends for the way that I am parenting. I am trying to trust my instincts and my baby’s needs, as you describe. Your posts are beautiful and give me comfort and confidence.

    Like

  42. rillarevolution Avatar
    rillarevolution

    What a fantastic letter to your daughter. I have boys now aged 3 and 5 and we did WIO (though didn’t know to call it that) – though I do like RIOT! My older boy settles himself to sleep beautifully now, and wakes up bright and breezy 11-12 hours later. My younger child takes himself to bed when he is tired and is asleep within 5 minutes. At times whilst we were journeying to here it felt a long road, but now, looking back it was a blink of an eye. I too found so much information telling me I was doing it wrong, I was spoiling or ruining them, that I was judging other people (by not doing what they were doing – never understood that to be honest). Finding your letter in those days would have been so heartening.

    Like

  43. […] As a proponent of attachment parenting, I love this description of the “wait-it-out method” as opposed to the cry-it-out […]

    Like

  44. Michelle Avatar
    Michelle

    My son will be 1 yr old next week and is still waking every 1-3 hours. I will be returning to work next month. I would be ok WIO if I didn’t have to return to work; I”m worried about how sleep deprivation would affect my job performance. Have any moms here WIO and worked full-time? If so, how did you manage? I’ve tried many other ‘sleep training’ methods, none worked. I have a hard time letting him CIO. Any advice would be appreciated. TIA

    Like

    1. sarah Avatar
      sarah

      Does his dad live in the same house? How many naps does he take during the day? What is his bedtime routine like?

      Like

    2. Lise Avatar
      Lise

      I went back to work when my daughter was 3.5 months old. She started sttn at 18 months. My dd is a night owl, so I would go to bed around 8 at night when she was done cluster feeding. I handed her to dh and went to sleep. He’d console her and hold her until she was really hungry, usually around 1030/11, and then bring her to me. We chose to bedshare, which was heaven and worked for us. All I had to do was pull down my shirt and she latched herself on. We did that on and off all night until my alarm went off at 6.

      During my days off, I napped with her. During my pumping breaks, I set a timer and relaxed (didn’t fall asleep, but just sitting and relaxing was helpful).

      My dd was down to 1-3 feedings at night at a year, and now nurses around 4 in the morning. I sleep through it all so it doesn’t bother me at all.

      Like

    3. Hannah Avatar
      Hannah

      Hi Michelle,

      I feel for you. That first year is challenging with sleep. But it does get better. I worked full time my daughter’s first year and she was not a good sleeper due to severe reflux. The only way we got through that year was bed sharing. We had a mini co-sleeper in the bed with us (although I wish we had a side car style) and I would just pull her in bed for nursing. Once we got the hang of it, I could fall back to sleep and then just switch her to the other side when she stirred. My husband would walk with her when she needed comforting. If you choose to try the bed sharing, maybe you can find a friend that can demonstrate in person how that works for them and how to do it safely. Once I got the hang of it, I ended up getting much more sleep than I ever would have if I had her in a crib and had to sit up feeding her. So did she.

      Like

  45. Michelle Avatar
    Michelle

    To add to the previous post, he is nursed and wakes up at night and will only fall back asleep if nursed

    Like

  46. Michelle Avatar
    Michelle

    I’ve tried co-sleeping when he was younger…did it for about 6 months. I have a hard time sleeping this way. Now that he is used to sleeping in his crib, he also seems to have a hard time co-sleeping, unless he is constantly nursing (basically using me as a pacifier). If i send my husband to him when he cries during the night, he will get mad and be up for 1-2 hrs whereas if i just nurse him back to sleep, it will take only 5 mins.
    So you moms who worked full time and woke up at night and WIO, you were able to function ok?

    Like

    1. Lise Avatar
      Lise

      Oh yeah. It wasn’t always the easiest thing, but neither is parenthood. For ME, functioning with a little less sleep was easier than considering not responding to my daughter’s needs.

      Like

    2. Vacationland Mom Avatar

      @Michelle- I went back to full-time office work at 3 months postpartum. My son is currently 22 months old and has never STTN (meaning atleast 7 hours in a row) and only a handful of times slept more than 4.5 hours at a stretch. He generally wakes up every 1-3 hours and will only be nursed back to sleep (we bedshare). If I try anything else… I don’t even like to think about it, it’s heartbreaking. I am able to function, but it took awhile… like I’d say until this past winter, before I felt like myself again, could remember phone numbers and stuff 🙂 My job isn’t very stressful or physically demanding so that definitely helps. I am still WIO… don’t know when it will change, feels like never, but when I read online about other people’s experiences I know it will get better.

      Like

  47. A little more on sleep « Woah Baby! Avatar

    […] As we continue to work out what sleep looks like for Del, and tangentially for me and Zach, I find this mother’s “sleep method” to be the ground on which I will sit. The entire post is worth reading, but here are some parts […]

    Like

  48. Samantha Avatar
    Samantha

    Beautifully written. As a FTM and early childhood educator, there are so many places that my training and my heart overlap. I am a firm believer in a combination of methods, what best suits your baby, but I loved loved loved reading your post!! I will definitely be getting in here every so often to see what other nuggets I can gain from you while I constantly learn my daughter’s (6weeks) tricks and trades!

    Like

  49. […] of sleep, this is about where I’m at now for sleep training: The Wait It Out (WIO) Method. (And a very touching post […]

    Like

Leave a reply to Joanna Cancel reply